New York City Slip & Fall Liability in the Snow

New York City law imposes clear obligations on property owners and managers to remove snow and ice from adjacent sidewalks. Under New York City Administrative Code §16-123, these parties must address snow and ice accumulation promptly after a snowfall. Failure to comply with these requirements can result in fines and other enforcement measures.

Demonstrating liability for pedestrian injuries caused by slippery sidewalks is not automatic. Courts and juries examine whether the property owner or manager complied with the statutory duty to clear snow and ice, the timing and thoroughness of the clearance efforts, and whether the injury resulted directly from any lapse in these responsibilities. Evidence such as maintenance records, weather data, and documented pedestrian activity is critical in assessing fault. As a result, slip and fall claims will be dismissed where it is shown that the owner’s or manager’s efforts were reasonable under the circumstances.

TalksOnLaw host Joel Cohen explains that while the statute clearly outlines the duty to maintain safe walkways, practical enforcement and litigation outcomes often limit successful claims. Nevertheless, property owners and managers remain accountable under the law. As a final note, this info is intended as a general guide—if you're dealing with an actual injury or a liability risk, it’s best to speak with a lawyer who can review your situation.